Jensen Harris, former director of person expertise (UX) at Microsoft, has taken subject with the design of Home windows 11’s Begin menu – Microsoft’s flagship of UX.
Harris, who performed a key function within the design of the Home windows 8 Begin menu with touch-friendly tiles, believes the Home windows 11 Begin menu has complicated components and distractions and even appears His PC is “contaminated with a virus.”
The designer aired his criticisms in a sequence of tweets explaining the significance of the Begin menu and declaring some weaknesses within the design.
“The Begin Menu is Microsoft’s flagship person expertise. It ought to signify the perfect UI design the corporate has ever enabled.” Harriso wrote,
“In the present day I found ‘chrome’ in Home windows and was shocked by the person expertise.”
Harris thinks Microsoft’s advert within the Begin menu selling the “Bing Wallpaper app” makes it seem like it was teleported from the Net 1.0 GeoCities period. “Truthfully, seems to be like I used to be contaminated with a virus. The textual content is flawed and it is sitting on prime of a Home windows Vista-era background,” he tweeted.
See: Finest Home windows Laptop computer 2022: Comparability of Prime Notebooks
As well as, the left nook of the advert is rounded – consistent with Microsoft’s redesign of the Home windows 11 app window – however the suitable has a pointy nook, whereas the underside left is a hybrid of the 2 and appears like “somebody sitting on a squirk.” Gone” .
For years, Microsoft has used adverts within the Begin menu to advertise first- and third-party apps from the Microsoft Retailer. Many customers didn’t like them. Till not too long ago, it “unintentionally” put adverts on the prime of the File Explorer window.
Harris is just not a fan of adverts within the Begin menu.
“The large subject right here although: Why are there banner adverts within the Begin menu? Is the quantity of $ made by this wallpaper app value it to cheapen individuals’s expertise on this very high-touch piece of UI? It erodes belief. -I used to be not even trying to find ‘wallpaper’.”
He’s very vital of Microsoft utilizing the Begin menu to advertise the Chromium-based Microsoft Edge browser. As Harris notes, Microsoft positioned that advert the most important within the Begin menu and famous “it is particularly designed to distract me from reaching the duty I need.” Microsoft is aggressively selling the brand new Edge browser in hopes of weaning Home windows 11 customers away from Google Chrome.
Then there’s the “design-challenging toolbar” that comprises a “salmon-colored Band-Help” button with a Bing icon for “Open leads to browser” that features two different buttons. The buttons are additionally disproportionately spherical and sq..
For Home windows 11, Microsoft opted to center-align the Begin button on the taskbar as an alternative of to the left the place it has historically been. Harris thinks the center-aligned Begin button was a mistake that does not seize the worth of customers changing into aware of their left place.
“I believe shifting the Begin button to the center of the taskbar wasn’t a superb transfer. The nook location not solely had a long time of muscle reminiscence, but it surely additionally perfected Fitt’s Regulation to make it ideally simpler to focus on.” Took benefit. Worse for the mouse, worse for the contact,” he writes.
Fortunately it seems to be just like the designers at Microsoft are nonetheless listening to their former colleague. Harris famous that Microsoft has “many good designers who care deeply about their work”.
Inside 24 hours of their criticism, Microsoft eliminated the Bing wallpaper advert and made some design enhancements.
Harris had totally different phrases on Home windows 11 Begin Menu UX that it’s potential to strike a stability between UX and monetizing desktop house.
“Keep in mind: Design is just not the enemy of monetization. The tradeoffs may be arduous to work out, however nice person expertise actually enhances nice advertising and monetization. Expertise design is the good friend of enterprise success, as a result of it results in these merchandise.” that folks like to make use of,” he has written,